Below is a huge list of retired beanie babies and their prices. Search here to see if your beanie baby is on this list, and see how much its worth! This list also includes rare beanie babies. Beanie Baby Price 1997 Teddy $37 1998 Teddy $45 Ally the alligator $32 Ants the anteater $11 Baldy the eagle $16 Bernie the St. Bernard $11 Bessie the ...more»