Retired Beanie Babies List
Filed Under Beanie Babies, Selling Beanie Babies, Ty Beanie Babies | Leave a Comment
Below is a huge list of retired beanie babies and their prices. Search here to see if your beanie baby is on this list, and see how much its worth! This list also includes rare beanie babies.
| Beanie Baby | Price |
|---|---|
| 1997 Teddy | $37 |
| 1998 Teddy | $45 |
| Ally the alligator | $32 |
| Ants the anteater | $11 |
| Baldy the eagle | $16 |
| Bernie the St. Bernard | $11 |
| Bessie the brown and white cow | $55 |
| Blackie the bear | $14 |
| Blizzard the tiger | $17 |
| Bones the dog | $13 |
| Bongo the monkey | $18 |
| Bongo the monkey with brown tail and red tush tag with no name | $80 |
| Bongo the monkey with tan tail and red tush tag with no name | $65 |
| Bronty the brontosaurus | $1200 |
| Brownie the brown bear | $4000 |
| Bruno the terrier | $12 |
| Bubbles the black and yellow fish | $140 |
| Bucky the beaver | $27 |
| Bumble the bee | $850 |
| Caw the crow | $450 |
| Chilly the polar bear | $1750 |
| Chocolate the moose | $14 |
| Chops the lamb | $130 |
| Claude the crab | $13 |
| Congo the gorilla | $15 |
| Crunch the shark | $9 |
| Cubbie the bear | $23 |
| Curly the bear | $18 |
| Coral the tie-dyed fish | $190 |
| Daisy the cow | $9 |
| Derby the fine mane horse | $450 |
| Derby the horse with no spot on head | $21 |
| Digger the orange crab | $525 |
| Digger the red crab | $125 |
| Doby the doberman | $15 |
| Doodle the rooster | $30 |
| Dotty the dalmation | $16 |
| Ears the rabbit | $13 |
| Echo the dolphin | $15 |
| Fetch the golden retriever | $12 |
| Flash the dolphin | $95 |
| Fleece the lamb | $12 |
| Flip the white cat | $28 |
| Floppity the rabbit | $16 |
| Flutter the butterfly | $820 |
| Freckles the leopard | $14 |
| Garcia the tye-dyed bear | $175 |
| Glory the bear | $27 |
| Goldie the goldfish | $35 |
| Gracie the swan | $11 |
| Grunt the razorback pig | $275 |
| Happy the hippo | $17 |
| Happy the gray hippo | $465 |
| Hippity the rabbit | $16 |
| Hoot the owl | $33 |
| Hoppity the rabbit | $18 |
| Humphrey the camel | $1600 |
| Inch the worm | $18 |
| Inch the inchworm with felt antennae | $105 |
| Inky the octopus | $22 |
| Inky the tan octopus without a mouth | $365 |
| Inky the tan octopus and with a mouth | $385 |
| Jolly the walrus | $13 |
| Kiwi the toucan | $165 |
| Lefty the donkey with American flag | $350 |
| Legs the frog | $26 |
| Libearty the white bear with American flag | $360 |
| Lizzy the lizard | $26 |
| Lizzy the tie-dyed Lizzy | $725 |
| Lucky the ladybug | $19 |
| Lucky the ladybug with 7 felt dots | $85 |
| Lucky the ladybug with 21 small dots | $310 |
| Magic the dragon | $36 |
| Manny the manatee | $140 |
| Maple the Canadian bear with Pride tush tag | $470 |
| Mystic the fine mane unicorn | $500 |
| Mystic the unicorn with tan horn | $30 |
| Nana the monkey with tan tail | $1650 |
| Nip the cat | $20 |
| Nip the all gold cat with pink ears and no white on paws | $570 |
| Nip the gold cat with white on face and belly | $280 |
| Nuts the squirrel | $13 |
| Patti the platypus | $21 |
| Patti deep fuchsia | $1200 |
| Patti the platypus (raspberry) | $1300 |
| Patti the platypus (magenta) | $1300 |
| Peanut the elephant | $16 |
| Peanut the royal blue elephant | $5200 |
| Peking the panda bear | $1600 |
| Pinchers | $15 |
| Pinky the flamingo | $15 |
| Pumkin’ the pumpkin | $22 |
| Puffer the puffin | $10 |
| Punchers (NOT Pinchers) the red lobster | $4550 |
| Quackers the duck | $20 |
| Quackers the duck with no wings | $2300 |
| Radar the bat | $170 |
| Rex the tyrannosaurus | $1100 |
| Righty the elephant with American flag | $350 |
| Ringo the racoon | $13 |
| Roary the lion | $15 |
| Rover the dog | $20 |
| Santa | $25 |
| Scoop the pelian | $13 |
| Scottie the terrier | $24 |
| Seamore the seal | $135 |
| Seaweed the otter | $25 |
| Slither the snake | $1150 |
| Sly the fox | $12 |
| Sly the fox with brown belly | $90 |
| Snip the cat | $14 |
| Snort the bull | $10 |
| Snowball the snowman | $35 |
| Sparky the Dalmatian | $135 |
| Speedy the turtle | $34 |
| Spike the rhinoceros | $13 |
| Spinner the spider | $10 |
| Splash the whale | $150 |
| Spook the ghost | $160 |
| Spooky the ghost | $33 |
| Spot black and white dog WITHOUT the spot | $1200 |
| Spot the black and white dog WITH the spot | $55 |
| Squealer the pig | $30 |
| Steg the stegosaurus | $1150 |
| Sting the stingray | $213 |
| Stinger the scorpian | $11 |
| Stinky the skunk | $13 |
| Stripes the tiger | $17 |
| Tabasco the red bull | $270 |
| Tank the armadillo 7 line with old tag | $160 |
| Tank the armadillo 9 line new star tag with no shell | $1500 |
| Tank the armadillo with shell | $70 |
| Teddy old face-brown | $1150 |
| Teddy old face-cranberry | $1250 |
| Teddy old face-jade | $1150 |
| Teddy old face-magenta | $1150 |
| Teddy old face-teal | $1250 |
| Teddy old face-violet | $1300 |
| Teddy new face-brown | $85 |
| Teddy new face-cranberry | $1550 |
| Teddy new face-jade | $1550 |
| Teddy new face-magenta | $1550 |
| Teddy new face-teal | $1750 |
| Teddy new face-violet | $1650 |
| Trap the mouse | $1070 |
| Tuck the walrus | $140 |
| Tuffy the terrior | $16 |
| Tusk the walrus | $155 |
| Twigs the giraffe | $19 |
| Valentino the bear | $23 |
| Velvet the panther | $30 |
| Waddle the penguin | $16 |
| Waves the whale | $17 |
| Weenie the dog | $20 |
| Web the spider | $1115 |
| Wise the owl | $20 |
| Wrinkles the dog | $12 |
| Zero the penguin | $20 |
| Ziggy the zebra | $13 |
| Zip the cat | $45 |
| Zip the all black cat with pink ears and no white on paws | $1050 |
| Zip the black cat with white face and belly | $250 |
| Beanie Baby | Price |
|---|---|
| 1997 Teddy | $37 |
| 1998 Teddy | $45 |
| Ally the alligator | $32 |
| Ants the anteater | $11 |
| Baldy the eagle | $16 |
| Bernie the St. Bernard | $11 |
| Bessie the brown and white cow | $55 |
| Blackie the bear | $14 |
| Blizzard the tiger | $17 |
| Bones the dog | $13 |
| Bongo the monkey | $18 |
| Bongo the monkey with brown tail and red tush tag with no name | $80 |
| Bongo the monkey with tan tail and red tush tag with no name | $65 |
| Bronty the brontosaurus | $1200 |
| Brownie the brown bear | $4000 |
| Bruno the terrier | $12 |
| Bubbles the black and yellow fish | $140 |
| Bucky the beaver | $27 |
| Bumble the bee | $850 |
| Caw the crow | $450 |
| Chilly the polar bear | $1750 |
| Chocolate the moose | $14 |
| Chops the lamb | $130 |
| Claude the crab | $13 |
| Congo the gorilla | $15 |
| Crunch the shark | $9 |
| Cubbie the bear | $23 |
| Curly the bear | $18 |
| Coral the tie-dyed fish | $190 |
| Daisy the cow | $9 |
| Derby the fine mane horse | $450 |
| Derby the horse with no spot on head | $21 |
| Digger the orange crab | $525 |
| Digger the red crab | $125 |
| Doby the doberman | $15 |
| Doodle the rooster | $30 |
| Dotty the dalmation | $16 |
| Ears the rabbit | $13 |
| Echo the dolphin | $15 |
| Fetch the golden retriever | $12 |
| Flash the dolphin | $95 |
| Fleece the lamb | $12 |
| Flip the white cat | $28 |
| Floppity the rabbit | $16 |
| Flutter the butterfly | $820 |
| Freckles the leopard | $14 |
| Garcia the tye-dyed bear | $175 |
| Glory the bear | $27 |
| Goldie the goldfish | $35 |
| Gracie the swan | $11 |
| Grunt the razorback pig | $275 |
| Happy the hippo | $17 |
| Happy the gray hippo | $465 |
| Hippity the rabbit | $16 |
| Hoot the owl | $33 |
| Hoppity the rabbit | $18 |
| Humphrey the camel | $1600 |
| Inch the worm | $18 |
| Inch the inchworm with felt antennae | $105 |
| Inky the octopus | $22 |
| Inky the tan octopus without a mouth | $365 |
| Inky the tan octopus and with a mouth | $385 |
| Jolly the walrus | $13 |
| Kiwi the toucan | $165 |
| Lefty the donkey with American flag | $350 |
| Legs the frog | $26 |
| Libearty the white bear with American flag | $360 |
| Lizzy the lizard | $26 |
| Lizzy the tie-dyed Lizzy | $725 |
| Lucky the ladybug | $19 |
| Lucky the ladybug with 7 felt dots | $85 |
| Lucky the ladybug with 21 small dots | $310 |
| Magic the dragon | $36 |
| Manny the manatee | $140 |
| Maple the Canadian bear with Pride tush tag | $470 |
| Mystic the fine mane unicorn | $500 |
| Mystic the unicorn with tan horn | $30 |
| Nana the monkey with tan tail | $1650 |
| Nip the cat | $20 |
| Nip the all gold cat with pink ears and no white on paws | $570 |
| Nip the gold cat with white on face and belly | $280 |
| Nuts the squirrel | $13 |
| Patti the platypus | $21 |
| Patti deep fuchsia | $1200 |
| Patti the platypus (raspberry) | $1300 |
| Patti the platypus (magenta) | $1300 |
| Peanut the elephant | $16 |
| Peanut the royal blue elephant | $5200 |
| Peking the panda bear | $1600 |
| Pinchers | $15 |
| Pinky the flamingo | $15 |
| Pumkin’ the pumpkin | $22 |
| Puffer the puffin | $10 |
| Punchers (NOT Pinchers) the red lobster | $4550 |
| Quackers the duck | $20 |
| Quackers the duck with no wings | $2300 |
| Radar the bat | $170 |
| Rex the tyrannosaurus | $1100 |
| Righty the elephant with American flag | $350 |
| Ringo the racoon | $13 |
| Roary the lion | $15 |
| Rover the dog | $20 |
| Santa | $25 |
| Scoop the pelian | $13 |
| Scottie the terrier | $24 |
| Seamore the seal | $135 |
| Seaweed the otter | $25 |
| Slither the snake | $1150 |
| Sly the fox | $12 |
| Sly the fox with brown belly | $90 |
| Snip the cat | $14 |
| Snort the bull | $10 |
| Snowball the snowman | $35 |
| Sparky the Dalmatian | $135 |
| Speedy the turtle | $34 |
| Spike the rhinoceros | $13 |
| Spinner the spider | $10 |
| Splash the whale | $150 |
| Spook the ghost | $160 |
| Spooky the ghost | $33 |
| Spot black and white dog WITHOUT the spot | $1200 |
| Spot the black and white dog WITH the spot | $55 |
| Squealer the pig | $30 |
| Steg the stegosaurus | $1150 |
| Sting the stingray | $213 |
| Stinger the scorpian | $11 |
| Stinky the skunk | $13 |
| Stripes the tiger | $17 |
| Tabasco the red bull | $270 |
| Tank the armadillo 7 line with old tag | $160 |
| Tank the armadillo 9 line new star tag with no shell | $1500 |
| Tank the armadillo with shell | $70 |
| Teddy old face-brown | $1150 |
| Teddy old face-cranberry | $1250 |
| Teddy old face-jade | $1150 |
| Teddy old face-magenta | $1150 |
| Teddy old face-teal | $1250 |
| Teddy old face-violet | $1300 |
| Teddy new face-brown | $85 |
| Teddy new face-cranberry | $1550 |
| Teddy new face-jade | $1550 |
| Teddy new face-magenta | $1550 |
| Teddy new face-teal | $1750 |
| Teddy new face-violet | $1650 |
| Trap the mouse | $1070 |
| Tuck the walrus | $140 |
| Tuffy the terrior | $16 |
| Tusk the walrus | $155 |
| Twigs the giraffe | $19 |
| Valentino the bear | $23 |
| Velvet the panther | $30 |
| Waddle the penguin | $16 |
| Waves the whale | $17 |
| Weenie the dog | $20 |
| Web the spider | $1115 |
| Wise the owl | $20 |
| Wrinkles the dog | $12 |
| Zero the penguin | $20 |
| Ziggy the zebra | $13 |
| Zip the cat | $45 |
| Zip the all black cat with pink ears and no white on paws | $1050 |
| Zip the black cat with white face and belly | $250 |
